Competitor comparison pages: your options for getting them built, and the fairness rules to follow
Short answer: You can get competitor comparison pages ("us vs them" and "alternatives to them" pages) built four ways: write them yourself, hire a freelancer, hire an agency, or use an AI workflow such as a Ploybook in Ploy (an AI marketing platform that builds and runs websites). Whoever drafts them, you must be able to prove every claim about a rival, date every price, and say where the rival is better, because the US Federal Trade Commission (FTC), the government body that polices advertising, says comparative advertising is legal only if it is truthful.
You have a competitor who shows up when your customers search, and you want a page that answers the comparison fairly. The risk is not writing it. It is publishing a claim about a rival that you cannot back up.
I'm Ranjit, and I run Blur Studio: 15+ years building software, 120 apps taken live, and clients who have gone on to raise $10M+. I build AI systems and processes that help businesses do a lot more with a lot less time. I also work differently from most of what else is out there, more on that further down this page. Say hello.
The direct answer: the best way to get comparison pages built is the one where a person on your side checks every claim before it goes live. A freelancer, an agency or an AI workflow can draft the page. None of them can take responsibility for what you publish about another company. That stays with you.
This page compares the four routes, sets out the fairness rules, gives you a claim log template, and shows where Ploy fits and where it does not. It is information, not legal advice.
This page may contain affiliate links from which Blur Studio earns commissions.
Two page types, two jobs
An "alternatives to X" page targets people who already know a rival and are unhappy or comparing. It lists several options, including yours. An "X vs Y" page sets two products side by side. People who search "X vs Y" are close to buying, so these pages are often your most valuable ones. Our page on docs, pricing and comparison pages that rank covers how they fit into a software company's site. This page is about getting them made, and doing it safely.
The rules you must follow whoever writes the page
- Proof before publishing. The FTC's advertising guide for small business says the law requires that advertisers have proof before the ad runs, and that a reasonable basis means objective evidence that supports the claim. It also says an advertiser must at minimum have the level of evidence it says it has. A statement like "tested" needs a real test.
- Truthful comparison is legal. The same guide says comparative advertising is legal as long as it is truthful. It also notes that competitors can sue under the Lanham Act (a US trademark and false advertising law) or go to the National Advertising Division (an advertising self-regulation body run through the Better Business Bureau), and that the FTC cannot step into a dispute between two companies. So a rival's complaint can reach you even if the FTC never does.
- Naming a rival and using its logo. Rules on trademarks differ by country and by use. Do not assume naming a rival is always allowed. Check the trademark office's current guidance and ask a lawyer before using logos or implying endorsement.
- Disclose what you earn. If you earn money when readers sign up for a product you recommend, put a note next to the link. The FTC's endorsement guidance says a connection a reader would not expect should be disclosed clearly and conspicuously.
- Be useful, not just promotional. Google's reviews system guidance says it rewards insightful analysis and original research, and treats head-to-head comparisons and ranked lists as reviews. Its advice for writing high-quality reviews includes giving evidence of your own experience, quantitative measurements, explaining what sets something apart from competitors, and covering benefits and drawbacks. It does not say comparison pages are penalised. A page that is thin, one-sided or copied is simply less likely to be helpful.
The FTC's guide points readers to its Comparative Advertising Policy Statement for more. That document and the trademark rules on using a rival's name are for the regulator's own pages and a lawyer to confirm, so check them there.
Four ways to get the pages built
| Route | Cost | Speed | Main risk | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Do it yourself | Free, your time | Slow, one page per week or two | Bias, missing facts, pages that never get updated | A founder with deep product knowledge and a few rivals |
| Freelancer | Quote only or hourly | Moderate | Writer does not know your product or the rival's | Three to ten pages with a clear brief |
| Agency | Quote only | Moderate to slow, includes strategy | Cost and generic output across many clients | A full content plan with research and design |
| Ploy workflow | AI credits on a plan | Fast draft, slow checking | Unverified rival claims in an AI draft | Many pages, with your own fact check |
Option 1: do it yourself
Build a single template with the same sections on every page: who each product is for, a feature table, prices with an "as of" date, where the rival is better, where you are better, and who should pick which. Keep a spreadsheet of claims (see the log below). The strength of this route is accuracy, since you know your own product. The weakness is that the first draft is biased and the pages go stale. Put a review date on every page and in your calendar.
Option 2: a freelancer
A freelance writer or product marketer can produce pages faster, but they need your facts. Cost varies a lot: one agency's 2026 cost guide lists freelancers at $30 to $100 an hour, and other seller-published pages give other ranges, so treat any range as a rough guide and ask for quotes. Give the freelancer your template, a feature checklist, your claim log and a rule that anything not in the log gets cut or checked. Ask them to log the source URL and the date they read it for every rival claim.
Option 3: an agency
An agency makes sense when the comparison pages are one part of a larger content and search plan, including page design, internal links and tracking. The FTC's guide also says an advertising agency can be held responsible for misleading claims and has a duty to check the evidence itself, so do not treat an agency as a substitute for your own claim log. Ask for scope in writing: how many pages, who verifies rival facts, who updates prices, and who owns the pages at the end. Our page on alternatives to a web agency retainer covers cheaper structures if a monthly retainer is too much.
Option 4: Ploy, one option among several
Ploy is an AI marketing platform from Ploy, Inc. You chat with an AI agent that builds and updates pages, and the platform also hosts the site. Its reusable workflows, called Ploybooks, include one named "competitor-alternatives-page" in the library listed on ploy.ai/ploybooks, which has 47 workflows in total. Each run uses AI credits, and custom Ploybooks are allowed on every plan. See our Ploybooks explained page for how they work.
The plan facts, as of November 2026 on ploy.ai/pricing: Free is $0 with 500 AI credits a day up to 2,000; Starter is $50 a month ($480 billed yearly) with 4,000 credits a month; Pro is $300 a month ($2,880 billed yearly) with 24,000 credits a month; Enterprise is by quote and adds done-for-you Ploybook setup. Credits do not roll over. Ploy does not publish a credit cost per action, so run one page and see what it uses before you plan a batch.
Ploybooks can run on demand or on a schedule. New schedules end after 90 days by default, with a reminder three days before. For comparison pages, a schedule is useful for one thing: a regular reminder to re-check rival prices. It should not publish unreviewed changes. AI-written pages need human review before publishing. An AI draft of a comparison can state a rival's price or feature from an older source, and only you can check that against the rival's own page.
The claim log: the habit that keeps you safe
This is the single most useful thing to add, and most competing pages do not mention it. Keep one row per factual claim about a rival.
| Claim | Source URL | Date read | Read by | Review again |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rival's paid plan starts at $X a month, billed yearly | Rival's pricing page | 2026-11-21 | Name | Quarterly |
| Rival's plan includes feature Y | Rival's help article | 2026-11-21 | Name | Quarterly |
| Rival has no feature Z | Rival's feature list and a test account | 2026-11-21 | Name | Monthly |
Rules for the log. Only the rival's own pages, or a test you ran, count as proof for what a rival offers. A review site or a blog is a lead, not proof. If you cannot confirm a claim, cut it, or tell the reader to check the rival's page. Never fill the gap with a guess. "No feature Z" claims are the riskiest, because the feature may exist on a plan or page you did not open.
Fairness rules for the page itself
- Date everything. Write "as of November 2026, check the vendor page" next to every price and plan limit. Show the billing basis, monthly or yearly, and the currency shown on the page. Do not convert currencies.
- Include a "where they are stronger" row. A page that says your product wins every row is not believed, and it is more likely to contain a claim you cannot prove.
- State who should pick which. End with "pick them if" and "pick us if" lists.
- No sale prices. A rival's limited-time price changes by the week. Link to the page and let the reader see the live figure.
- Correction path. Put an email address on the page for rival corrections, and fix errors fast. Note the date of each change.
- One URL per comparison. A page per pair is easier to update than a long page covering ten rivals.
Worked example with made-up numbers
A fictional 4-person company, Brightbook, sells appointment software for salons and wants pages against two rivals. All numbers are invented to show the arithmetic.
- Pages needed: Brightbook vs Rival A, Brightbook vs Rival B, and "Rival A alternatives". That is three pages.
- Route A, do it yourself: 6 hours per page for research and writing, plus 2 hours of review, so 24 hours total. At a made-up internal cost of $50 an hour, that is $1,200 of time.
- Route B, freelancer at a made-up $60 an hour: 5 hours per page, so 15 hours or $900, plus 6 hours of Brightbook's own fact checking, valued at $300. Total $1,200.
- Route C, Ploy on Starter at $50 a month: drafts in an afternoon, but Brightbook still spends about 3 hours per page checking claims, so 9 hours or $450 of time, plus $50 for the month. Total $500.
The lesson is not that the AI route wins. It is that the checking time is the same on every route, and it is the part you cannot hand off. The made-up Ploy figure also assumes the credits cover three drafts, which you would confirm by running one page first.
When another route is better
- Skip Ploy for this job if you do not want to move your site onto a new platform, or if you only need two or three pages. A freelancer or your own time costs less than learning a new tool.
- Pick a freelancer when the pages need strong writing and a clear point of view, and you can supply the facts.
- Pick an agency when comparison pages are part of a larger search plan and you want design, tracking and strategy done together.
- Do it yourself when you have under five rivals, a small budget, and a founder who can write clearly.
- Do not build pages against rivals you cannot check. Pages about a competitor's private contract terms, security or reviews are where claims go wrong.
Copy-ready checklist before you publish
- Every claim about a rival has a row in the claim log with a source URL and a date.
- Every price has "as of", the billing basis and the currency shown.
- The page has a "where they are stronger" section written by someone who has used both products.
- No logo use or endorsement implied; trademark questions checked.
- Affiliate or referral links are disclosed near the link.
- A named person approved the page, and the review date is in the calendar.
- The page has a correction email address.
How I'd approach this
I would write one comparison page by hand first, with the claim log, so I know what a good page looks like. Then I would decide on the route for the rest. If I wanted volume and was happy to move the site, I would try a single Ploybook draft in Ploy on the Free plan, and compare its draft with my hand-written one. I would not publish any AI page until each rival fact was checked against the rival's own page.
If you need a custom version, with AI agents that use your business knowledge, connections to your CRM and calendar, a half-built flow finished, or ongoing care, Blur Studio builds that. See what the business work includes.
First-week plan. Day 1: list the three rivals people name most often in sales calls. Day 2: build the claim log and read each rival's pricing and feature pages. Day 3: write one page by hand with a "where they are stronger" section. Day 4: have someone who has used the rival read it. Day 5: publish, add the review date to your calendar, and decide the route for the next batch. For a related list, see Semrush alternatives as an example of the alternatives format, and Ploy vs Wix for a vs-page example.
Related guide: Can Clients Pay for Their Own Website Plan? Billing Options for Agencies.
Related guide: Agency Partner Programs for Website Platforms: Referral Options.
Related guide: Slack Alerts for New Leads: Options From Free to Paid.
Related guide: Who Changed What? How to Keep a Record of Website Edits.
Related guide: Developers and Marketers on the Same Website: Code and Chat Together.
Questions people ask
Is it legal to name a competitor on a comparison page?
The FTC's advertising guide for small business says comparative advertising is legal as long as it is truthful, and that you need proof before the ad runs. Trademark rules on using a rival's name or logo differ by country, so check the trademark office's current guidance and ask a lawyer. This is information, not legal advice.
How much does it cost to have comparison pages built?
It depends on the route. Doing it yourself costs your time. Freelancers and agencies quote by page or by project, and seller-published hourly ranges vary widely, so ask for quotes. Ploy charges by plan, as of November 2026 Starter is $50 a month, and it does not publish a credit price per run, so test one page first. See Ploy pricing.
Can AI write my competitor comparison pages?
AI can draft the structure and the text, and a Ploy workflow exists for it. It cannot confirm what a rival offers today. Check every rival fact against the rival's own page, log the source and date, and have a person approve the page before it goes live.
Will Google penalize my vs pages?
Google's guidance does not say comparison pages are penalised. Its reviews system guidance says it rewards insightful analysis and original research and treats head-to-head comparisons as reviews. Pages that are thin or one-sided are simply less helpful. Add evidence, drawbacks and who each product suits.
How often should I update a comparison page?
Review prices and plan limits at least quarterly, and sooner for features that change often. Put an "as of" date on each price, a review date in your calendar, and a correction email on the page. A scheduled reminder, including a Ploy schedule, can prompt the review, but remember Ploy schedules end after 90 days by default.
Should I mention where the competitor is better?
Yes. A page that says you win every row is less believable and more likely to hold a claim you cannot prove. Google's own review guidance asks for benefits and drawbacks. Name the rival's real strengths and say who should pick them.
What if the competitor says my page is wrong?
Check the claim against your log and the rival's current page. If you were wrong, fix it quickly and note the date. If you were right, keep the source on file. For a serious dispute, talk to a lawyer rather than arguing in public.
Do I need to disclose affiliate links on a comparison page?
Yes, when you earn from a referral. The FTC says a connection readers would not expect should be disclosed clearly and conspicuously, so put the note near the link. See our page on partner and affiliate programs for how Blur Studio treats it.
More in this topic: Websites: agency billing, partners and team workflows (6 guides) →