Simple website builders compared: Ploy against Notion, Super and Carrd
Short answer: Carrd, a builder for one-page sites, is the cheapest and simplest choice when one page does the job. Notion, a workspace app for notes and documents that can publish pages as Notion Sites, and Super, a paid tool that turns Notion pages into a branded website, fit sites you already write in Notion. Ploy, an AI marketing platform that builds and hosts a full multi-page site by chat and adds analytics and forms, costs more and makes sense only when you need more than a simple site.
You want a small, simple site: a landing page, a link page, a portfolio, a company page written in Notion. Four tools claim to do it, at very different prices. The right one depends on how big the site will get and who will edit it.
I'm Ranjit, and I run Blur Studio: 15+ years building software, 120 apps taken live, and clients who have gone on to raise $10M+. I build AI systems and processes that help businesses do a lot more with a lot less time. I also work differently from most of what else is out there, more on that further down this page. Say hello.
The direct answer: if you need one page with a form and your own domain, use Carrd. If your content already lives in Notion and you want it public with your branding, use Notion Sites or Super. If you need many pages, a blog, search tracking, tests and a site an AI agent can keep updating, look at Ploy. Pay for the least tool that does the job, and move up only when the job grows.
Prices below come from the vendors' own pages as of November 2026. Check the vendor's page for the billing basis before you pay, since several pages do not state it.
This page may contain affiliate links from which Blur Studio earns commissions.
What each tool is
- Carrd is a builder for simple, mostly one-page sites. You pick a layout, edit sections, and publish. Its paid Pro plans add custom domains, forms, widgets, embeds and analytics.
- Notion is a workspace app where teams write notes, documents and databases. Its Notion Sites feature publishes a Notion page to the web, with a notion.site address or, if you pay for it, your own domain.
- Super is a separate paid service that turns Notion pages into a website with its own design, domain, custom code and search settings. It is not made by Notion.
- Ploy is an AI marketing platform from Ploy, Inc., a San Francisco company founded in 2025. You chat with its AI agent to build multi-page sites, which it hosts, with analytics, forms and a database that can turn rows into pages. Its Ads and Grow product pages are waitlists, so this page covers the website side.
When a one-page site is enough
A one-page site is enough when the visitor needs one thing: read a short story, then do one action. These jobs fit one page well:
- A link page for social media, or a business card site for a freelancer.
- A waitlist or "coming soon" page that collects emails.
- An event or webinar page with a date, a short agenda and a sign-up button.
- A single offer page you point ads or emails at.
- A resume or portfolio with a few projects and a contact link.
It stops being enough when you need a page for each service, a blog, a page for each location, or search traffic that needs many pages answering many questions. Google ranks pages, not sites, so one page can compete only for one topic. If you plan search traffic, read how to get a small business website live this week and plan for several pages.
Prices from the vendor pages
| Tool | Plans shown | Billing and caveats |
|---|---|---|
| Carrd | Pro Lite $9 a year (3 sites), Pro Standard $19 a year (10 sites), Pro Plus $49 a year (25 sites). Larger packs of sites cost more. | Billed yearly, auto-renew or pay as you go, 7-day Pro trial without payment details. Free plan limits are not listed on the Pro page, so check Carrd. Currency shown as "$". |
| Notion (the workspace) | Free $0, Plus $10, Business $20, Enterprise custom, per member per month in USD, billed yearly. | Monthly billing is $12 for Plus and $24 for Business; the page says yearly saves up to 20%. |
| Notion Sites | Free: basic sites, basic search indexing, one notion.site domain. Plus: custom sites (header, theme, favicon, Google Analytics), 5 notion.site domains. Business and Enterprise: advanced search indexing. | A custom domain, which removes Notion branding, costs $8 a month per domain billed annually or $10 monthly. The page does not say which plans can buy it. |
| Super | Free $0, Personal $16 a month, Pro $28 a month. Custom build from $250. | Custom domain, custom code and search settings are listed for paid plans. Multi-site packs run $4 to $7 per site. The page shows "$" with no named currency and does not label monthly or yearly, so check. You also need a Notion account for the content. |
| Ploy | Free $0, Starter $50 a month or $480 billed yearly, Pro $300 a month or $2,880 billed yearly, Enterprise custom. | Starter includes 1 domain family and 4,000 AI credits a month, and credits do not roll over. The free plan has no custom domain. Check Ploy's pricing page for your usage. |
Put the cheapest sensible setup side by side: Carrd Pro Standard at $19 a year against Ploy Starter at $480 a year. That is about 25 times the cost. Ploy is not overpriced for what it does, but you should not pay for multi-page growth tools if you run a link page. For a fuller look at Ploy's own prices see Ploy pricing explained.
Side by side by job
| Job | Best fit | Why |
|---|---|---|
| One landing page or link page | Carrd | Cheapest, quick to build, forms and a custom domain on Pro |
| Public docs, a help center or a handbook you already write in Notion | Notion Sites or Super | You edit where you already work |
| Branded site from Notion with custom code and search settings | Super | It adds design control on top of Notion pages |
| Multi-page business site edited by staff | Ploy or a larger builder | Pages, forms and analytics in one place |
| Hundreds of pages from a spreadsheet | Ploy | Its database makes a page from each row |
| Testing two versions of a page | Ploy, if switched on for your workspace | Ploy has experiments, enabled by request through its sales team |
| A site you may want to download and host yourself | Carrd Pro Plus, or Ploy's code export | Carrd lists "download sites" on Pro Plus, Ploy's docs list a git clone export (a command that copies the site's code) on every plan |
Export and exit rules for Notion Sites and for Super are not stated on their pricing pages, so ask both before you build something you cannot afford to lose. Ploy's terms say you keep your data and content and give you 30 days to export it after termination, while its privacy policy says 60 days, so plan for the shorter one.
Weaknesses of the simple tools
- Few pages. Carrd is built around one page, and large sites get awkward. Notion and Super handle many pages but give you less control over layout than a design tool.
- Search control. Notion Sites' free plan has basic search indexing, with advanced indexing on Business and Enterprise. Super lists search settings on paid plans. If search traffic matters, check what you can edit: page titles, descriptions, redirects and a sitemap.
- Forms and tracking. Carrd forms and analytics start on Pro. Check whether forms send leads where you need them. See forms, booking and payments on your website.
- Dependence on one app. A Super site depends on Notion and on Super. If either changes pricing or terms, you carry the risk.
Where Ploy is the weaker pick
- For a single page, it costs far more, and its free plan has no custom domain.
- It is new, and the big review sites (G2, Capterra and Trustpilot, where customers rate software) had no listing for it as of November 2026.
- AI-built pages need a person to review the text, links and forms.
- Credits run out. Ploy publishes no price per action, so heavy editing by chat can use a plan up before the month ends.
- Its agent works best on a site with real content. A page of three sentences does not need it.
Who should skip Ploy
- You need one page or a link page. Use Carrd.
- Your content lives in Notion and you want it public. Use Notion Sites or Super.
- You want the lowest cost and can accept limits.
- You need a person on the phone. Ploy offers email, a community and a status page, with no stated response time.
Checklist: pick in ten minutes
- How many pages will the site have in a year? One: Carrd. Under ten: any of the four. Dozens or more: Ploy or a larger builder.
- Where does the content live? In Notion: Notion Sites or Super.
- Who edits it? Only you: any. Several staff who are not technical: check the editing screen with a real change.
- Do you need a custom domain? All four need a paid plan for it.
- Do you need forms that reach your customer records? Check each tool's form and integration page.
- Do you need search traffic? Plan several pages and check search settings.
- Could you leave in a day? Ask what export means for that tool, and test it on a copy.
A worked example with made-up numbers
Take a freelance photographer who needs a portfolio with eight pages and a contact form. Made-up facts: no blog, one editor, a custom domain wanted.
- Carrd Pro Standard: $19 a year plus the domain. Eight sections on a one-page layout, or several separate Carrd sites linked together. Cheapest, with a long single page.
- Notion Site on Plus with a custom domain: $10 a month for the member plus $8 a month for the domain billed annually, so about $216 a year if the $10 is billed monthly. The page structure is easy but design control is limited.
- Super Personal: $16 a month if billed monthly, or $192 a year, plus a Notion account.
- Ploy Starter: $480 a year billed yearly. More than this site needs.
The photographer picks Carrd. If the same person later adds a blog, location pages and a booking funnel, the answer changes. The point of the exercise is to price the job you have, not the job you might have.
Need something completely custom?
Everything above is a path to get it running quick and cheap. But sometimes none of these fit, and what you need is something custom that you own, built uniquely for your business from the ground up, with AI thoughtfully designed into the parts of it that your processes actually benefit from. An asset that grows in value, not a generic, one-size-fits-all boilerplate that's an expense with a lock-in. This is a complete bespoke build, and it's something I do very well. Get in touch to know more.
How I'd approach this
I would start with the smallest tool that fits and write down the trigger for moving up. For a first site, that trigger is usually "I need more than three or four pages" or "I want to track and test what visitors do". At that point, Ploy or another multi-page builder is worth a trial, and you can read what an AI website builder is and how to build a business website without a developer first.
If your site is a core part of the business, a custom build that you own may suit you better than any of these. Blur Studio builds that version, with AI agents that use your business knowledge, connections to your customer records and calendar, half-built sites finished, and ongoing care: see what the business work includes.
First-week plan: on day 1 list the pages you need in a year. On day 2 pick the smallest tool from the checklist and open its free plan or trial. On day 3 build the main page and send yourself the form test. On day 4 check the page on a phone, and ask the vendor how export works. On day 5 buy the plan and the domain, in your own name. You can also try Ploy's free plan for a day to compare.
Questions people ask
Is Carrd good enough for a business website?
For a one-page business site with a contact form, yes, and it costs about $19 a year on Pro Standard (as of November 2026). For a site with many services, locations or a blog, a multi-page tool fits better. See best AI website builders for small business.
Can I use a custom domain with a Notion site?
Yes. Notion's pricing page lists a custom domain at $8 a month per domain billed annually or $10 billed monthly, and a custom domain removes Notion branding. The page does not say which plans can buy it, so check before you build.
Do I need Super if I have Notion Sites?
Not always. Notion Sites covers basic public pages. Super is a separate paid tool that adds design control, custom code and search settings on top of Notion pages. If you do not need those, Notion Sites may be enough.
Is Ploy worth it for a small simple site?
Usually not. Ploy's paid plans start at $50 a month, and its value is in multi-page sites, analytics, forms, tests and AI updates. For a single page, Carrd costs a fraction. See what Ploy's free plan includes if you want to test it first.
What are the best Carrd alternatives?
It depends on the job. Notion Sites or Super suit content you already keep in Notion, and a multi-page builder such as Ploy suits a growing business site. Our page on free website builders lists what free plans really include.
Can I export a Carrd or Notion site?
Carrd's Pro page lists "download sites" as a Pro Plus feature without explaining it, so check what you get. Notion Sites and Super export rules are not stated on their pricing pages, so ask them. Ploy's docs say its git clone export works on every plan, and you should confirm that for your plan.
Will a one-page site rank on Google?
It can rank for the one topic it answers, but it has little room to answer other questions. For search traffic, plan separate pages for each service or question, and check titles and descriptions. No tool can promise rankings. See how to check and edit your website titles and descriptions.
How do I move from Carrd or Notion to a bigger site later?
Keep the same page addresses where you can, and add 301 redirects (permanent forwarding) for any that change. Ploy can rebuild a site from its public address, and the result is a rebuild, not an identical copy. See Ploy site migration.
More in this topic: Ploy.ai: compared with website builders and AI builders (8 guides) →