A scheduler test plan: Blotato vs Buffer vs Postiz on the same week of posts

By Ranjit Bhinge, founder of Blur Studio · Updated · 11 min read

Short answer: This page is a test you run yourself, not a set of results. Blur Studio has not run Blotato (a software subscription that writes, designs and schedules social media posts), Buffer (a long-running social media scheduling tool) or Postiz (an open source scheduler you can use as a hosted service or run on your own server) on a week of posts, so there is no winner here. You get a design for sending the same 7 posts through each, a blank results table, a failure log, list prices as of November 2026 and a decision rule you set before you start.

Ranjit Bhinge

You want to know which of Blotato, Buffer and Postiz is better for your own posts, and the only fair way to find out is to send the same week of posts through all three and write down what happens.

I'm Ranjit, and I run Blur Studio: 15+ years building software, 120 apps taken live, and clients who have gone on to raise $10M+. I build AI systems and processes that help businesses do a lot more with a lot less time. I also work differently from most of what else is out there, more on that further down this page. Say hello.

Most comparisons of these three tools are price tables and feature lists. They cannot tell you how many minutes a post takes you, how often a post fails, or whether your formatting survives. A test can. This page gives you the whole test: the posts, the accounts, the log, the cost sums and the rule for choosing.

One thing first. Nobody at Blur Studio has run this test, so I am not going to invent a results table. The results table below is blank on purpose. Where I give numbers, they are list prices from the vendors' pages, or arithmetic on made-up inputs that I label as made up.

This page may contain affiliate links from which Blur Studio earns commissions.

What the test answers, and what it does not

It answers five practical questions for your account mix and your habits.

  1. How many minutes does it take to set up and to schedule a week of posts in each tool?
  2. How many of the posts publish on time, late or not at all?
  3. What breaks, with the exact error text?
  4. What does each tool cost for your number of accounts, and what does the time cost on top?
  5. Which tool passes your must-have list?

It does not answer which tool gets more reach. Reach depends on your posts, not on the tool that sent them, and one week is far too short to see it. The piece on whether posting through a scheduler hurts reach covers that question separately.

The three tools in plain words

Blotato charges a flat monthly price for a set number of connected accounts and adds AI writing, images and short video. Its help pages list 11 destinations: X (the network formerly called Twitter), LinkedIn (the professional network), Facebook, Instagram (photo and video sharing), Pinterest (a picture pinboard site), TikTok (short video), Threads, Bluesky, YouTube, Slack and Discord (team chat apps). It has a 7 day trial that needs a card, and it has no free plan.

Buffer charges per connected channel (one social account), has a free plan for 3 channels, and offers a 14 day trial of paid plans without a card. Its approval workflows are on the Team plan only.

Postiz charges by plan, each with a channel allowance, lists about 30 destinations on its pricing page, and has a 7 day free trial on every plan. Its code is public under the AGPL-3.0 licence (a free software licence that requires you to share changes if you offer the software as a service), so you can run it yourself. The Standard plan lists no team support, while Team and above list unlimited team members.

Design: the same 7 posts, one week

Accounts

If you send the same post to the same account from three tools, you create duplicates and you cannot tell which tool did what. The clean design is three throwaway accounts on one platform, one per tool. Bluesky (an open social network with short text posts) or Threads (Meta's text network) both take every post type below. Use test accounts at least 1 to 2 weeks old, because Blotato's help centre advises warming up new Threads and Bluesky accounts by hand for that long, and an age gap between accounts would skew the result. Keep these accounts for testing only: do not post test content to your business accounts or your audience, and delete the test posts afterwards.

If you cannot make three accounts, use the fallback: run the same 7 posts through one tool per week on three weeks in a row, using the same account. The drawback is that the weeks differ, so only compare publishing behaviour, not any reach number.

The 7 posts

Write every text under 280 characters. That fits X, Threads (500) and Bluesky (300) without edits, so a failure is not just a length problem. Use identical files in every tool.

DayPostWhat it checks
MonText onlyPlain text
TueSingle imageImage upload
WedText with a linkLink handling
ThuThread of 3 partsThreads and ordering
FriShort video under 60 secondsVideo upload and wait
SatText, set for 23:55 your timeTime zone and date edge
SunText with emoji and line breaksFormatting survives

Extra checks, not counted in the 7: schedule one post 8 days ahead and confirm it sits in the queue; move one scheduled post to a new time; remove one scheduled post and confirm it does not publish. In Blotato's web app the documented way to take a scheduled post out of the queue is Move to Drafts, not a delete button, so schedule it first and then use that.

Rules for the week

  • Schedule all 7 posts in one sitting per tool, in the same order, and time yourself.
  • Do not create an API key in Blotato (a secret code that lets other software control your account). Blotato says creating one ends the trial and starts the paid plan. The test only needs the web app.
  • Do not fix a failed post silently. Log it first, then fix it, then log the fix time.
  • After each post's time, wait 10 minutes, then check the post on the network itself, not only in the tool.
  • Define "on time" before you start: published within 5 minutes of the set time.

Results table (blank, fill it in)

Copy this into a spreadsheet. Fill one column per tool.

MeasureBlotatoBufferPostiz
Minutes to connect the account
Minutes to schedule all 7 posts
Posts published on time (of 7)
Posts published late
Posts failed or missing
Posts needing a manual fix
Minutes spent on fixes
Formatting changes you saw (count)
Extra checks passed (queue, move, delete) of 3
Analytics visible after 7 days (yes or no, which numbers)
Support contacts and time to a useful reply
Plan price, monthly billing, for your account count
Extra costs (credits, add-ons, server)

Failures: what counts, and how to log it

A failure is anything that makes the post differ from what you set. Use these categories so the three columns mean the same thing.

CategoryHow you spot itWhat to write down
Not publishedNot on the network 10 minutes after the set timeStatus shown in the tool, exact error text, time
Published lateLive, but more than 5 minutes after the set timeMinutes late
Wrong timeLive at a different hour, often a time zone issueSet time, actual time, time zone shown in the tool
Formatting changedLine breaks, link preview or emoji differ from your draftScreenshot of draft and live post
Media problemImage cropped, video missing, upload refusedFile size, format, message
DuplicateSame post live twiceBoth times, what you did before it happened
Says published, not liveTool shows success, the network shows nothingBoth screenshots, post link if any

Some failures are the network's rule, not the tool's. Blotato's help pages say Instagram posts need an image or video, that Threads takes one image or video per post, and that X text is capped at 280 characters. If you test on Instagram as well, Blotato says a text-only post will fail there, and other tools may behave the same way, so do not count it against one tool without checking. Record the exact message, then check which side the limit is on. The platform limits cheat sheet lists them with dates.

Cost: list prices and the time you spend

These are list prices as of 21 November 2026, in US dollars, on monthly billing for every tool. Never compare one tool's monthly price with another's yearly price.

AccountsBlotatoBuffer EssentialsPostiz
3$29 (Starter)$0 on the Free plan, or $18 paid$29 (Standard, 5 channels)
5$29$30$29
10$29$60$39 (Team, 10 channels)
20$29 (Starter, 20 accounts)$100$49 (Pro, 30 channels)
30$97 (Creator, 40 accounts)$135$49 (Pro, 30 channels)

Arithmetic for Buffer: it charges $6 a channel for channels 1 to 10, then $4 for channels 11 to 25 and $3 for channels 26 to 50. Twenty channels is 10 x $6 plus 10 x $4, which is $100. Thirty channels is $60 plus 15 x $4 plus 5 x $3, which is $135. Buffer's Team plan, which has the approval workflows, is $12 a channel for the first 10.

On yearly billing the figures drop. Buffer shows $5 a channel a month for Essentials. Postiz's FAQ gives $23, $31, $39 and $79 a month for its four plans. Blotato says yearly billing saves about 17 percent (you pay for 10 months and get 12), which is about $24.17 a month for Starter by my arithmetic, and it is switched in Blotato's billing portal rather than shown as a price. Blotato's AI credits (its unit for image and video generation) are included up to a monthly allowance, and Postiz lists AI images from its Team plan up, so read each page if you plan to make media.

The cost the price table hides: your time

Use this formula. Monthly cost = plan price + (posts a month x minutes per post / 60 x what an hour of your time is worth). Here is a worked example with made-up inputs: 60 posts a month and your time valued at $30 an hour. The minutes are invented, and your test fills in the real ones.

Made-up toolPlan priceMinutes per postHours a monthTime valueTotal
Tool A$2922$60$89
Tool B$3033$90$120
Tool C$2944$120$149

Two minutes more per post, over 60 posts, is 2 extra hours, which is $60 at this assumed rate. That is more than the whole plan price. If your measured minutes per post differ by even one minute between tools, that is an hour a month at 60 posts, which can matter more than a $1 or $20 price gap. For the same reason, self hosting Postiz is free to license but not free to run: log the hours you spend installing, updating and fixing it, and add a server bill.

Where each tool may win, per the vendors' own pages

These are things to confirm in your test, not results.

  • Buffer: a free plan for 3 channels, a trial without a card, approvals and unlimited users on Team, and a two year analytics history on paid plans, per its pricing page. It is the one to beat for 1 to 4 channels and for any team that needs sign off.
  • Postiz: a wider destination list than the other two (Reddit and Telegram are on its list, and neither is on the other two), the option to host it yourself, and API, webhooks and an MCP server (a standard that lets an AI assistant use a tool) on every plan.
  • Blotato: one price for up to 20 accounts, and AI writing, images and short video inside the same tool that publishes. Check its credits, since one long video clip can use a lot of a Starter month.

When not to use Blotato

Skip Blotato, or at least drop it from the test, if any of these is true.

  • You have 4 accounts or fewer and want a free plan. Buffer's Free plan covers 3 channels at no cost, and Blotato has none.
  • Someone must approve every post before it goes out. Blotato has no approval link or review feature, and Buffer Team and several other tools do. See Blotato approval workflows.
  • You need several people with their own logins. Blotato accounts are for one user.
  • You need Reddit or Telegram posts, or Google Business Profile posts. Postiz lists all three, and Blotato lists none.
  • You want to run the software on your own server. Postiz offers that, Blotato does not.
  • LinkedIn is your main channel and you need first comments or comment replies there. Blotato does not support those on LinkedIn.

Decision rule (set it before you start)

  1. Write your must-haves first: platforms, approvals, users, budget ceiling.
  2. Drop any tool that misses a must-have on the plan you would pay for.
  3. Of the rest, drop any tool with fewer than 6 of 7 posts on time, or any wrong account or duplicate post.
  4. For those left, work out the monthly cost with the time formula above, using your measured minutes.
  5. Pick the lowest total. If two are within $10, pick the one whose support reply and error messages were clearer in your log.
  6. If none pass, run a second week with the changes you can fix, or keep your current method.

The 6 of 7 mark and the $10 band are my rule of thumb, not a standard. Change them, but change them before the test, not after.

How this page was checked

Prices and limits come from the vendors' own pages: Blotato's pricing page and help centre, Buffer's pricing page and its plain text price list, Postiz's pricing page and its public code page. Last checked 21 November 2026, refreshed every 90 days. All totals are my arithmetic on list prices. Blur Studio has not run Blotato, Buffer or Postiz itself, so please test with the 7 day Blotato trial, Buffer's Free plan or trial, and Postiz's 7 day trial before you pay. Vendor comparison pages are written by the vendor, so I do not copy them, and review site ratings are left out.

How I'd approach this

I would run the test in one week, with no more than 90 minutes a day. Day 1: make or pick three test accounts, write the 7 posts and prepare the files. Day 2: set up the results sheet and your must-have list, then start with a Blotato trial, remembering that it asks for a card and that you should not create an API key. Day 3: schedule the 7 posts in Blotato and time yourself, then do the same in Buffer's Free plan. Day 4: do it in Postiz's trial. Days 5 to 7: check each post on the network, log failures and note the support reply times. On day 7, apply the rule.

If you would like a second pair of eyes on your numbers, the free AI tools at /free and a free AI brainstorm call are there for that. For more, see Blotato vs Buffer, Blotato vs Postiz and the 7 day trial scorecard.

Questions people ask

Are there results on this page?

No. Blur Studio has not run the three tools on a week of posts, so the results table is blank on purpose. The page gives you the design, the log and the rule so you can run it yourself.

Can I connect the same account to all three tools?

You can, but each tool will publish to it and you will get duplicates, which spoils the test. Use one throwaway account per tool, or run the tools in turn on separate weeks.

Do I need to pay for any of the three to run this?

Not necessarily. Buffer has a free plan for 3 channels and a 14 day trial without a card, Postiz has a 7 day free trial, and Blotato has a 7 day trial that needs a card. Cancel before the trial ends if you do not want to continue. See what the Blotato trial includes.

Why not create a Blotato API key for the test?

Blotato says creating an API key in Settings ends the trial at once and starts the paid plan. A test of the web app does not need one. See whether Blotato has an API.

Is Postiz really free?

Its code is public under the AGPL-3.0 licence, so you can run it yourself at no licence cost. You still pay for the server and your time, and the hosted version has paid plans. Check Postiz's pricing page for the current figures.

Why is Buffer $5 on some pages and $6 on others?

Buffer shows $5 a channel a month for Essentials on yearly billing and $6 on monthly billing. Team is $10 yearly and $12 monthly. This page uses monthly billing for every tool.

How many posts do I need for a fair test?

Seven posts are enough for a first look at publishing reliability and time per post, not reach. If you want to test what content performs better, use the 30 day content experiment instead.

More in this topic: Social media: growth, calendars and routines for solo owners (36 guides) →

Sources

Ready for the next step?

A free 15-minute AI brainstorm. We find 3 broad areas where AI could help your business.

Ranjit Bhinge You talk to me, Ranjit. I reply within a few hours.
Book a free AI brainstorm call

Not sure what you need? Tell me what is going on. I will point you the right way, even if it is not me.

Blur Studio · 30 minute call

Book a 30 minute call

You talk to me, Ranjit. If you do not need me, I will tell you.

  • We talk about your business and what is going on.
  • You leave with a clear next step, even if it is not me.
  • I reply to every message within a few hours.
Loading the calendar…